Will global populism continue to erode democracies? -

Will global populism continue to erode democracies?

Credit: washingtonpost.com

  • Sep 13 2017 12:02About: 2 months ago
  • 8 views

In this file photo, Poland’s opposition party Nowoczesna leader Ryszard Petru (C) with other parliamentarians hold a card reading ‘#Free Media in Sejm’ during a protest in Sejm, the lower house of the Polish parliament in Warsaw, Poland, December 16, 2016. The ruling Law and Order Party had proposed rules limiting news media access to the parliament. (EPA/MARCIN OBARA)

As we head into election season in Europe, the question that dominated the past spring’s elections remains on everyone’s mind: What will be the fate of populist movements, parties and candidates? I reached out to Stanford University political scientist Anna Grzymała-Busse, who just guest-edited a special issue of Slavic Review on “Global Populisms.” What follows is a lightly edited version of our discussion.

JT: You recently were the guest editor of a special online issue of Slavic Review on “Global Populisms.” First off, what exactly do you mean by that term?

AGB: We hear a lot about populism — but it is both an amorphous concept and very diverse set of movements and parties. Populists (as defined by University of Georgia political scientist Cas Mudde) seek to represent the interests of “the people” against what they view as a corrupt and collusive elite establishment.

“Global populisms” refers both to the widespread popularity of these appeals — and their very different manifestations across the world, ranging from the left-wing populism of Hugo Chávez and Nicolás Maduro in Venezuela to the welfare chauvinism of the Danish People’s Party to the conservative nationalism of the Polish Law and Justice Party.

JT: What was the impetus behind the special issue?

AGB: The major catalyst was the erosion of liberal democracy under populist rule in Poland and in Hungary. Populism has been rising in popularity across Europe, but in these two countries, after populists gained power, they proceeded to politicize and neuter the constitutional courts, limit media access and freedoms, rewrite electoral laws, and divide society into “better” and “worse” sort of citizens.

As scholars primarily of post-communism, we also wanted to take stock both of the diversity of populism in the region, and how it manifests itself in different settings and over time. So one goal here was to document the very distinct forms of populism in one relatively small region and address their prevalence. Populist parties have also governed Slovakia (HZDS in the 1990s and Smer-SD from 2006 to 2010 and again since 2012), and they are important political players in Bulgaria, the Czech Republic, Lithuania, Romania and Slovenia, among others.

We also examine how populist movements manifest themselves in different domains: how they exploited economic reforms that eroded the state; how transnational ties begin to link the nativist far-right; and the ways in which populist parties have evolved (from nationalism to the radical left, in one prominent example).

JT: You wrote one of the articles. What was the main argument of your piece?

AGB: I argue that the weakness of mainstream parties allows populists to take power. Centrist parties that respond to electoral concerns and offer distinct policy alternatives are on the wane. Populists can then not only claim the mantle of representing popular interests in the face of mainstream party indifference, but they also can gain the votes and seats to govern with supermajorities. These enormous majorities then allow them to govern without coalition partners and preclude effective parliamentary checks. In both Poland and in Hungary, these parties have more freedom than ever to erode the formal institutions of liberal democracy and the informal norms that underpin them.

JT: Looking forward, where do you see the trajectory of global populism heading in the medium-term future, say, the next three to five years?

AGB: It’s here to stay. If I’m right about mainstream parties and their weakness, then even with the best of intentions and resources it will take some time before the center-left, in particular, can rebuild. Many of its problems are structural: the collapse of the working-class coalitions, the constraints on policymaking due to international pressures and so on. Center-right parties have actively gone after these voters, and transformed themselves in the process. For example, in Poland and in Hungary, the ruling populist parties used to be conservative, and then adopted a far more nativist, xenophobic, and populist set of appeals that criticize the democratic establishment for not representing the “real” Poles and Hungarians.

There are no easy fixes. That said, there has been a bit of a backlash against these parties after Brexit and the election of President Trump — for example, in the Austrian presidential elections in December, in the Dutch elections in March, or most recently, in the French elections in May. But even in France, 40 percent of voters supported Jean-Luc Melenchon and Marine Le Pen, each of whom offered a populist message.

JT: Where can our readers find the articles in the special issue, and how long will they be available?

AGB: The entire issue is available here, and it will remain ungated until the end of the year.



Follow Us on Twitter

Related stories with Will global populism continue to erode democracies?

The Killers air rarities, debut new material and bring out Woody Harrelson for ‘intimate’ Brixton Academy show -World News
The Killers air rarities, debut new material and bring out Woody Harrelson for ‘intimate’ Brixton Academy show 2 months ago
Check out the photos, footage and setlist from The Killers' epic and intimate gig at London's O2 Academy Brixton with Woody Harrelson
Spandau Ballet reveal reason why Tony Hadley left the band, and why he isn’t welcome back -World News
Spandau Ballet reveal reason why Tony Hadley left the band, and why he isn’t welcome back 2 months ago
Spandau Ballet have said that former frontman Tony Handley isn’t welcome to return to the band after quitting earlier this year.
Louise Redknapp relaunches pop career, announces tour -World News
Louise Redknapp relaunches pop career, announces tour 2 months ago
Louise Redknapp has relaunched her pop career after announcing a live gig, set to take place at the end of the year.
How to Check If You’re Exposed to Those Scary BlueBorne Bluetooth Flaws -World News
How to Check If You’re Exposed to Those Scary BlueBorne Bluetooth Flaws 2 months ago
They allow a virus to leap from device to device, regardless of the operating system.
This Morning viewers outraged as Madam compares losing brothel to child dying -World News
This Morning viewers outraged as Madam compares losing brothel to child dying 2 months ago
THIS MORNING viewers were left fuming today after a Madam explained that she felt like she had lost a child when her brothel was closed down, claiming her to be "insensitive".
Toys
Toys "R" Us: No Game Changer For Vornado Realty 2 months ago
One thing is quite clear as it relates to Vornado, the company has seen considerable shareholder value erode because of euphoric deal making.
Peter Foster: You’re invited to the climate ‘conversation.’ Just keep your mouth shut -World News
Peter Foster: You’re invited to the climate ‘conversation.’ Just keep your mouth shut 2 months ago
When you're invited to join conversations, too often this means stepping into a social media echo chamber
Holly Willoughby reveals she's 'happy and healthy' after dramatic weight loss and insists her 'Willough-boobies' are intact -World News
Holly Willoughby reveals she's 'happy and healthy' after dramatic weight loss and insists her 'Willough-boobies' are intact 2 months ago
The This Morning presenter admitted she has more time to herself now her three children are older
Frankie Essex gets fat shamed on holiday and vows never to wear a bikini again after gaining weight -World News
Frankie Essex gets fat shamed on holiday and vows never to wear a bikini again after gaining weight 2 months ago
The Essex babe has put a few pounds back on after a crippling knee injury
Love Island's Olivia Attwood covers up nipples with love hearts as she slips back into tiny bikini -World News
Love Island's Olivia Attwood covers up nipples with love hearts as she slips back into tiny bikini 2 months ago
The reality star went makeup-free as she posed in a jacuzzi
Russell Westbrook Signs the Biggest Shoe Deal in Jordan Brand History -World News
Russell Westbrook Signs the Biggest Shoe Deal in Jordan Brand History 2 months ago
NBA MVP Russell Westbrook has just signed a mega 10-year extension deal with Nike's Jordan Brand, the most lucrative endorsement deal for a Jordan athlete thus far according to Nick DePaula of ESPN. Westbrook is currently in the middle of his current cont