Right to free speech and expression of scholars must be factually tempered -

Right to free speech and expression of scholars must be factually tempered

Credit: timesofindia.indiatimes.com

  • Oct 23 2017 05:45About: 27 days ago
  • 7 views



A country's history reflects the flow of events through centuries. Penning events of the recent past factually is not very difficult. But dispassionate factual narration of a country's historical events, though extremely difficult, is a necessity. For, it will tell future generations about events, incidents and personalities that shaped the country, its polity, society and culture. Historians had the privilege, patience and perseverance to rummage through voluminous documents with independent sources and the government and those preserved in archives to cull out a narrative which we read as history in schools and went a fraction deeper if we evinced interest in the subject in college and university level.



Leaders who played important roles in events that shaped the country's history had expressed their mind through speeches or actions. Historians read and researched historical evidence and archived material to frame a sequence of events and narrate it in a story form. Did they keep out their personal impression from the narration?



A certain class of documented events and speeches of historical leaders could evoke varied perceptions in an individual, including historians, who too exercised their right to free speech and expression while narrating history. This information, written by historians according to their perception, given to future generations through history books determines the reputation and dignity enjoyed by leaders of the past.



When today's events figure in tomorrow's history books, it is possible that it would be described as a period when communalism in the shape of cow vigilantism, riots and intolerance gagged the right to free speech. Development work of the government would possibly get buried under tonnes of material on intolerance. That will be a historian's right to free speech guided by individual perception of events.



But is right to misinformation also part of right to free speech and expression? And does misinformation affect the country's dignity, which influences and affects countrymen's collective right to dignity?



Projecting a historical figure on the basis of his deeds and completely ignoring his speeches, which give an insight into his traits, is misinformation. History, which we read in schools and colleges, is replete with such examples. The blame for such misinformation must go to some historians who, in exercise of right to free speech and expression, have to some extent played with citizens' right to information and the right to dignity, which they derive from the country's history.



Recently, many articles were written in newspapers on Sir Syed Ahmed Khan on his 200th birth anniversary. Glowing tributes must be paid to this man, who rose to the position of a subordinate judge, for having the vision to establish Muhammadan Anglo-Oriental College in Aligarh in 1875, which later blossomed into the educational hub called Aligarh Muslim University (AMU).



The vice-chancellor of a Hyderabad-based reputed law university wrote in a recent article, "Sir Syed's concept of nation was inextricably woven with secular ideals." He quoted Sir Syed's lecture in Patna in 1883: "My friends! This India of ours is populated by two famous communities, the Hindus and the Muslims. The two communities stand in the same relation to India in which the head and the heart stand in relation to the human body." He quoted another speech of Sir Syed in 1884 in Gurdspur, more or less on the same lines.



What he did not include in his narrative eulogising the AMU founder's secular credentials was Sir Syed's vitriolic reaction to the formation of Indian National Congress (INC) in December 1885, with bar-at-law Womesh Chandra Bonerjee as president. In his speech in Meerut in March 1888, Sir Syed called the Congress an organisation of Hindus aimed at annihilating Muslims and warned of catastrophe if such a design was ever put into practice.



Giving the example of then situation in Aligarh, Sir Syed said, "Dushera and Moharrum fell together for three years, and no one knows what took place. It is worth notice how, when an agitation was started against cow killing, the sacrifice of cows increased enormously, and religious animosity grew on both sides, as all who live in India know well."



Asking Muslims to be friends with the British and dissuading them from joining INC, Sir Syed said, "Therefore, we should cultivate friendship with them (British), and should adopt that method by which their rule may remain permanent and firm in India, and may not pass into the hands of Bengalis. This is our true friendship with our Christian rulers."



On the possibility of peaceful co-existence between Hindus and Muslims, Sir Syed said, "To hope that both could remain equal is to desire the impossible and the inconceivable. At the same time, you must remember that although the number of Mohammedans is less than that of Hindus, and although they contain far fewer people who have received high English education, yet they must not be considered insignificant or weak. Probably, they would be by themselves to maintain their own position. But suppose they were not. Then our Musalman brothers, the Pathans, would come out as a swarm of locusts from their mountain valleys, and make rivers of blood to flow from their frontiers on the north to the extreme end of Bengal."



Right to free speech and expression of historians and scholars must be factually tempered, for they bear the unenviable task of meeting the countrymen's important right to information and right to dignity.







Follow Us on Twitter

countrys history reflects flow events through centuries. Penning events recent past factually very difficult. dispassionate factual narration countrys historical events though extremely difficult necessity.

Related stories with Right to free speech and expression of scholars must be factually tempered

Editors Guild asks Raje govt to drop ordinance -World News
Editors Guild asks Raje govt to drop ordinance 27 days ago
NEW DELHI: The Editors Guild of India expressed deep concern over Rajasthan Government's decision to make the Criminal Laws (Rajasthan Amendment) Ordinance 2017 into an Act in the current legislative session here on Sunday. Urging CM Vas
14 Cong rebels to contest Gujarat polls on BJP ticket -World News
14 Cong rebels to contest Gujarat polls on BJP ticket 27 days ago
NEW DELHI: BJP is set to contest the forthcoming Gujarat assembly polls with 14 Congress rebel MLAs in the field, aiming to dampen Congress prospects on seats that the party has held. It hopes to add votes that have eluded the saffron party in an ele
Prasar Bharti to go digital, sell India story to world -World News
Prasar Bharti to go digital, sell India story to world 27 days ago
The proposed English language digital platform will focus on global economy, geopolitics, international terror, global crises and soft power. It has also proposed news items where DPB can control the discourse on environment, nature, animal rights and hum
Rex Tillerson to stress on India's role in Afghanistan plan -World News
Rex Tillerson to stress on India's role in Afghanistan plan 27 days ago
While Tillerson will visit Islamabad ahead of New Delhi during his five-nation trip, the US Secretary of State is expected to deliver a blunt message to Pakistan about cracking down on safe heavens of terror – a point highlighted by him during his recen
Modi congratulates Shinzo Abe on re-election -World News
Modi congratulates Shinzo Abe on re-election 27 days ago
Japanese PM Shinzo Abe got a resounding victory in the snap polls held on Sunday, with his LDF-led coalition winning two-thirds majority in the lower house of Parliament.
Indian Navy to review operational effectiveness at high-level meet Tuesday -World News
Indian Navy to review operational effectiveness at high-level meet Tuesday 27 days ago
In the backdrop of China’s increasing military presence in the Indian Ocean Region, the Indian Navy at a high-level meeting in Delhi starting from Tuesday will discuss plans to enhance its footprint in the region with a review of its operational effecti
Congress will give up to Rs 5,000 to jobless, homes to poor & write off farm loans: Ashok Gehlot -World News
Congress will give up to Rs 5,000 to jobless, homes to poor & write off farm loans: Ashok Gehlot 27 days ago
"The Modi government’s decision on demonetisation and implementation of the flawed GST has played havoc with Gujarat’s industry and trading sections," Gehlot said.
BJP talks of promises kept as PM Narendra Modi opens Ro-Ro ferry service -World News
BJP talks of promises kept as PM Narendra Modi opens Ro-Ro ferry service 27 days ago
BJP leaders termed the Ro-Ro ferry service a gift to Saurashtra and Saurashtrians living in other parts of the state as it would link southern Gujarat and Saurashtra.
Government may lower visa fee to attract tourists in lean season -World News
Government may lower visa fee to attract tourists in lean season 27 days ago
The idea, mooted by group of young CEOs at a recent Niti Aayog event, has found favour with the tourism ministry, which has started talks with the ministry of external affairs to work out the modalities.
US wants India to help strengthen capacities in Afghanistan -World News
US wants India to help strengthen capacities in Afghanistan 27 days ago
The Trump administration wants India to help strengthen Afghanistan's capacities and institutions so that the war-torn country can take on a resurgent Afghan Taliban based in neighbouring Pakistan, a senior US official has said.
Government, SC in favour of ethics body for legal profession -World News
Government, SC in favour of ethics body for legal profession 27 days ago
In an endeavour to usher in major reforms in the legal profession, the Centre and country’s highest court have also suggested the need to regulate professional fees.
5 things to know about Japan's pacifist constitution -World News
5 things to know about Japan's pacifist constitution 27 days ago
October 23, 2017 12:51 PMTOKYO (AFP) - Japanese Prime Minister Shinzo Abe's long-held dream to change the pacifist constitution got a big boost this weekend as his conservative coalition won a crucial two-thirds majority in a snap election.