5-year wait for surrogacy too long for those who marry late: Parl panel -

5-year wait for surrogacy too long for those who marry late: Parl panel

Credit: timesofindia.indiatimes.com

  • Aug 13 2017 07:09About: 2 months ago
  • 5 views



NEW DELHI: The five-year waiting period for couples to avail surrogacy is not only a breach of reproductive rights but also impairs chances of wannabe parents who marry late and want to go for assisted techniques, a Parliamentary committee has said.



The panel, which examined the Surrogacy (Regulation) Bill, termed the five-year waiting period as "arbitrary, discriminatory and without any definable logic" and recommended that the period be reduced to one year.



It said that in the present context of late marriages (late 30s and 40s) the requirement of five-year wait would adversely affect the quality of gametes and thus impair chances of couples attaining parenthood through surrogacy.



Also, in circumstances where the need for surrogacy is absolute due to medical reasons like absence of uterus, destruction of uterus because of cancers, fibroids among others, even the prescribed one year period should be waived, the committee said in its report.



"Besides, this time bar of five years plausibly violates the right to reproductive autonomy, and an individual's right to exercise his choice," the committee said.



It also suggested that the definition of infertility be made commensurate with the one given by the World Health Organisation (WHO).



The surrogacy bill was passed in the monsoon session of Parliament last year and was referred to a parliamentary standing committee.



The WHO terms infertility as "a disease of the reproductive system defined by the failure to achieve a clinical pregnancy after 12 months or more of regular unprotected sexual intercourse".



Though the definition of infertility is limited to failure to conceive only, there are other medical conditions for which surrogacy is availed.



For example, TB destroys thousands of uterus irreversibly. A large number of girls are born without a uterus or a very underdeveloped uterus. A large number of women have repeated miscarriages. There are many women who have their uterus removed because of cancer or because of many tumours.



"The fundamental right to reproduce to have a child is a part of a person's personal domain and fixing a period of five years will only cause breach of his/her reproductive rights and delayed or deferred parenthood," the committee said.



In India, infertility is considered a social stigma and infertile couples go through a lot of agony and trauma. Since, conception has many interplay functions, a five-year time bar would add to the misery of already distressed couples.



The committee strongly recommended that the Assisted Reproduction Technologies (ART) Bill, 2008 should be brought forth first before bringing in the surrogacy bill as surrogacy procedures cannot be conducted without assisted reproduction techniques and there is urgent need to regulate the ART clinics across the country.



"...mere enactment of the Surrogacy Bill would not serve the purpose of the controlling commercialisation of the surrogacy facilities across the country in the absence of regulation of ART and banks where surrogacy is being conducted as ART Clinics and surrogacy clinics are not separate," the committee said.



It observed that the ART Bill had been drafted in 2008 and revised in 2010 and 2014. Since then, it has been lying with the government.



On a specific query about the number of IVF/ART clinics in the country, the Department of Health Research apprised the committee that 1,035 clinics are registered with ICMR.



However, the actual number of such clinics is likely to be more.



According to unconfirmed reports, the number of surrogacy births in the country in the last three years is approximately 2,000.





Follow Us on Twitter

Parliamentary committee which examined Surrogacy (Regulation) Bill termed five-year waiting period arbitrary discriminatory without definable logic recommended that reduced year.

Related stories with 5-year wait for surrogacy too long for those who marry late: Parl panel

Modi may turn populist, shun major reforms till polls: Report -World News
Modi may turn populist, shun major reforms till polls: Report 2 months ago
Having achieved some success on the anti-graft drive (over Rs 4,313 crore black money have been unearthed since May 2014), PM Modi may play up this again, says the report.
UK to release Brexit plans in effort to bat away claims of muddled thinking -World News
UK to release Brexit plans in effort to bat away claims of muddled thinking 2 months ago
The British government is fighting back against criticism that it is divided and unprepared for Brexit, announcing it will publish a set of detailed proposals on customs arrangements, the status of the Ireland-Northern Ireland border and other issues. The
California Capital Airshow is Honoring an Unsung Hero! -World News
California Capital Airshow is Honoring an Unsung Hero! 2 months ago
Is there a hero in your community? Enter to win them the ride of a lifetime! 7UP and Raley’s have partnered with the California Capital Airshow to offer a unique opportunity for an ‘Unsung Hero’ from the Sacramento region to ride in an oh-so sle
Ryan Giggs' council house jibe to Manchester City fan who mocked him about fling with sister-in-law -World News
Ryan Giggs' council house jibe to Manchester City fan who mocked him about fling with sister-in-law 2 months ago
They clashed as the former Manchester United ace stepped off a train and fan shouted out of the window
Jordan Spieth admits PGA Championship is toughest of golf's majors for him -World News
Jordan Spieth admits PGA Championship is toughest of golf's majors for him 2 months ago
CHARLOTTE – Jordan Spieth never advanced from the doorstep of history this week in the 99th edition of the PGA Championship. The world No. 2, who was trying to become the youngest player to win the career Grand Slam, signed for another ho-hum round Satu
Five storylines for Sunday: Matsuyama's time? -World News
Five storylines for Sunday: Matsuyama's time? 2 months ago
Could Hideki Matsuyama finally break through and win a major? Here's what else to watch for as the season's final major draws to a close.
Thai authorities hunt for tourists handling sea creatures in Phuket -World News
Thai authorities hunt for tourists handling sea creatures in Phuket 2 months ago
August 13, 2017 12:54 PMPHUKET (THE NATION/ASIA NEWS NETWORK) - A Facebook user has drawn the attention of authorities in Phuket province to the possible illegal handling of sea creatures.
Rugby - Cheika feels for fans after Force chopped -World News
Rugby - Cheika feels for fans after Force chopped 2 months ago
The decision to dump the Western Force from Super Rugby was a massive disappointment for the team's "huge" supporter base, Wallabies coach Michael Cheika said on Sunday.
Gorakhpur hospital still gasping for breath as toll touches 60 -World News
Gorakhpur hospital still gasping for breath as toll touches 60 2 months ago
Of 30 children who died during the last 48 hours, 17 were in the neo-natal ward, five in the AES ward and eight in the general ward.
Sac State Student Saves Choking Man Moments Before Interviewing for Paramedic Internship -World News
Sac State Student Saves Choking Man Moments Before Interviewing for Paramedic Internship 2 months ago
SACRAMENTO — Sacramento State student Wil Stewart is too modest to say he saved a life, or that he’s a hero, but his mom isn’t. “He said, ‘Well I just saved a guy from choking,’ and I said, ‘What? What?'” sa
Roses for You. -World News
Roses for You. 2 months ago
Roses for You.   Roses you can go to blush. Going to enjoy. And water is pouring in the vase. They are a bunch steal with a beautiful flower. And i