Commentary: Apple Park and the trouble with modern workplaces -

Commentary: Apple Park and the trouble with modern workplaces

Credit: channelnewsasia.com

  • About: 9 days ago
  • 4 views

LONDON: The iPhone X was the focus of Apple's launch event on Tuesday, but the venue was equally alluring. Chief executive Tim Cook unveiled the device in the Steve Jobs theatre, a sleek auditorium at Apple Park, its new head office in Cupertino.

Apple Park, a US$5 billion campus for 12,000 staff with a vast circular building surrounding a park planted with oaks and fruit trees, is an emblem of the US technology industry's latest craze. An industry of start-ups founded in garages wants to redesign employee activity, and prod engineers to get up from their desks and exchange ideas.

Apple Park is "a building which is pushing social behaviour in the way people work to new limits", says Stefan Behling of Foster + Partners, its architects, in an official video.

Apple is not alone: Amazon is planning for a US$5 billion second head office and chipmaker Nvidia has built a two-story office with spaces at its heart to "spark collisions".

Their collective vision is as ambitious as that of Louis Sullivan, the architect of early US skyscrapers whose 1896 essay The Tall Office Building Artistically Considered declared loftiness to be "on a high road to a natural and satisfying art".

In Apple Park and the like, the contrast is that instead of skyscrapers that split staff across floors, companies are building utopias in wide, flat campuses.

But people do not always enjoy sparking collisions, or having their social behaviour altered.

A TECH UTOPIA?

As senior director of real estate at Nvidia John O'Brien says: "Human beings do not like change, and engineers like it the least."

There is reason to be reluctant about being made to mingle - people often get most done when left in peace.

The guilty secret of many corporate transitions to open-plan offices and hot-desking is the desire to save money. As work patterns become more flexible and technology makes remote working easier, one study had earlier found that the average desk is only occupied about half the time.

Allocating everyone a locker and telling them to find a free desk when they arrive costs less.

The tech industry is innocent in that respect. Its main motivation for reconfiguring these campuses is not cost but revenue - and the belief that innovation springs out of collaboration and that is inhibited by walls and floors.

While everyone has his or her own workstation at both Apple and Nvidia, these new buildings also allow them to gather and huddle when working together on projects.

ACTIVITY-BASED WORKING

The idea behind this is "activity-based working", an approach to office design pioneered in the mid-1990s in the Netherlands by consulting firm Veldhoen at companies including insurer Interpolis.

The theory goes, rather than staying in one place, staff should move around zones during the working day, depending on whether they are working normally, focusing quietly or collaborating.

But this can create uncertainty for employees, who have a human tendency to gravitate to one spot.

I found myself to be one of such employees, when told that the Financial Times was considering activity-based working in its return to its former London head office.

Likewise, some Apple engineers have been reported to be dismayed at having to work in newly designed open-plan "pods" at Apple Park.

A WASTE OF AMBITION AND MONEY

Activity-based working often does not operate as planned. A study by workplace research group Leesman found that while it boosts productivity, many employees stuck to familiar habits.

About 70 per cent of those in activity-based workplaces still anchored themselves to a single desk, which the study concluded made the office design "a catastrophic failure". It is a waste given the amount of ambition and money that goes into configuring these offices.

There must be something in it for employees or they will not change their ways, no matter how much companies abolish walls to create space or alter furniture.


Companies should start by recognising what their employees fear losing. The architecture firm Gensler that designed Nvidia's new building pointed out in one study that workers face "less space, less privacy … more distractions" in open-plan offices. Many have to spend more hours working.

It seems opportunities for collaboration have to be balanced with "extended periods of uninterrupted focus".

Companies also need to accept that not every kind of professional works in a similar way. Some jobs require the kind of constant moving from communal discussions to individual focus that activity-based working is designed to facilitate.

In other cases, employees work most efficiently in one place every day and prodding them to migrate around the office is a pointless distraction.

Sullivan wrote influentially that "form follows function" and concluded that in skyscrapers, "tiers of typical offices, having the same unchanging function, shall continue in the same unchanging form". This was the early 20th century template: Floor upon floor of small offices, "similar to a cell in honeycomb, merely a compartment".

A century later, the need for uniformity has been eroded by changes in technology and working patterns. The office of the 21st century performs a variety of functions and has to take on various forms.

Silicon Valley's campuses will work if they are flexible enough to allow diversity, but not if they are technology utopias that try to re-engineer the behaviour of the people inside.

© 2017 The Financial Times Ltd 2017. All rights reserved. Not to be redistributed, copied or modified in any way.

Follow Us on Twitter

Related stories with Commentary: Apple Park and the trouble with modern workplaces

Second place OK for Spieth for the next two weeks -World News
Second place OK for Spieth for the next two weeks 9 days ago
Jordan Spieth has said finishing runner-up over the next two weeks on the PGA Tour would suit him just fine.
Barclays wins end to U.S. litigation over pre-crisis disclosures -World News
Barclays wins end to U.S. litigation over pre-crisis disclosures 9 days ago
NEW YORK (Reuters) - Barclays Plc won the dismissal on Wednesday of U.S. class-action litigation by investors who bought its stock just months before the 2008 global financial crisis, and accused it of concealing its exposure to risky debt and an inabili
Jordyn Woods Says the Term Plus Size Can
Jordyn Woods Says the Term Plus Size Can "Create Segregation" 9 days ago
The up-and-coming model tells us why we should do away with labels.
Rihanna Is the #1 Fan of This Stunning New Bag -World News
Rihanna Is the #1 Fan of This Stunning New Bag 9 days ago
It's got the Riri stamp of approval, so you know it's good.
50% of UK’s visitor visas given to Chinese, Indians -World News
50% of UK’s visitor visas given to Chinese, Indians 9 days ago
Of the total 26.3 lakh visas issued by the UK during the last financial year, 20.38 lakh or 77% were for visitors alone. The aggregate number of visitor visas reflected a rise of 8% over the previous year ended June 30, 2016. Of the 20.38 lakh visitor vis
Former Hong Kong leader Leung Chun-ying did not declare new role as he was out of town -World News
Former Hong Kong leader Leung Chun-ying did not declare new role as he was out of town 9 days ago
Former Hong Kong leader Leung Chun-ying took 11 days to tell the government of his new appointment as a director at two companies because he was out of town, his office has said. It also said that Leung only needs to “inform” the government of
Randy Travis makes new legal move to block 2012 DWI arrest video -World News
Randy Travis makes new legal move to block 2012 DWI arrest video 9 days ago
Randy Travis is taking yet another legal step in an effort to block the video of his 2012 DWI arrest private. This time, the country singer has taken things to the federal level arguing that the release of the video could violate his personal medical priv
'Love is love': Will & Grace star Debra Messing on the marriage equality debate -World News
'Love is love': Will & Grace star Debra Messing on the marriage equality debate 9 days ago
With her Will & Grace stars in a chorus of agreement, Messing said: "I just can't imagine why anyone would begrudge someone's happiness."
Zayn Malik Talks Louis Tomlinson Reconciliation: ’It’s Not the Way it Used to Be’  -World News
Zayn Malik Talks Louis Tomlinson Reconciliation: ’It’s Not the Way it Used to Be’ 9 days ago
Zayn Malik and Louis Tomlinson might have made amends recently, but things between themThis article originally appeared on www.usmagazine.com: Zayn Malik Talks Louis Tomlinson Reconciliation: ’It’s Not the Way it Used to Be’
James 'Arg' Argent literally DRIBBLES over his food on Celebs Go Dating after saying he's got flirting
James 'Arg' Argent literally DRIBBLES over his food on Celebs Go Dating after saying he's got flirting "down to a tee" 9 days ago
EXCLUSIVE: The TOWIE star reckons he's got away with it ... but it's doubtful