The Wall Street Journal: The big snag in ethical investing -

The Wall Street Journal: The big snag in ethical investing

Credit: marketwatch.com

  • Sep 14 2017 09:50About: 2 months ago
  • 5 views

It is often claimed that socially responsible investors—those who incorporate social, environmental or other ethical concerns into the construction of a portfolio—can “do well by doing good.”

To the extent this claim has been challenged, most have examined whether such investors can truly “do well.” From an investment performance perspective, the answer appears to be yes. A 2017 TIAA analysis found no long-term, systematic performance penalties for leading socially responsible indexes relative to broad market benchmarks.

While not all studies have been as favorable toward socially responsible investing (SRI)—a 2008 paper in the Journal of Banking & Finance concluded that “existing studies hint but do not unequivocally demonstrate that SRI investors are willing to accept suboptimal financial performance to pursue social or ethical objectives”—the reality appears to be that differences in performance, if any, are small enough that socially responsible investors can still “do well.”

But it is less clear whether such investors are truly “doing good.” In fact, to make an informed decision about whether or not to engage in socially responsible investment strategies (particularly in light of the added cost that is involved), potential investors should be open to the possibility that such strategies may have little to no impact at all.

Unlike many good deeds we may do in life—picking up trash, donating to a good cause, or helping out someone in need—our actions in the stock market can often be easily (and profitably) reversed by others who may not share our nonfinancial motives.

Suppose a group of environmentally conscious investors decides to engage in fossil-fuel divestment. All else equal, their divestment will put downward pressure on equities within the fossil-fuel industry. Presumably many such investors also hope that such downward pressure will result in consequences such as reduced investment interest, a higher cost of capital for divested firms, corporate policy change, or some other effect that ultimately leads to a world with less fossil-fuel consumption.

But, unfortunately for those who may be motivated by the consequences of their divestment, putting downward pressure on fossil-fuel stocks based on nonfinancial criteria will actually increase the profit opportunities for investors who are not averse to investing in the fossil-fuel industry. Assuming that industry fundamentals remain the same, profit-minded investors can short the stocks overweighted by the environmentally conscious investors (that is, wherever environmentally conscious investors invest their divestment proceeds) and purchase fossil-fuel stocks, effectively canceling out the downward pressure socially responsible investors intended to apply.

Of course, not all investors may wish to engage in socially responsible investment merely for the consequences that result. Instead, some may feel it is morally wrong to profit off certain business activities, regardless of the consequences. Further, socially responsible investors may be motivated by consequences that may not show up in stock prices or that may only manifest beyond some threshold of market adoption.

For instance, they may feel that investing according to one’s values helps foster a broader culture of corporate responsibility, regardless of its impact on stock prices. Or perhaps such investors believe that beyond a certain threshold of SRI adoption, profit-minded investors will no longer have the collective power needed to prevent nonfinancial motives from influencing prices.

The key point, however, is to acknowledge that it shouldn’t be taken for granted that socially responsible strategies are “doing good.” In reality, some strategies may have little or no impact, and each should be evaluated on its own merits. And because socially responsible strategies generally come with a higher cost to consumers, investors should carefully consider both the true costs and benefits of any given strategy, as well as the ways in which a strategy fits within their broader moral perspective, before deciding to become a socially responsible investor.

Derek Tharp (@DerekTharp) is the founder of Conscious Capital and a research associate at Kitces.com.

The article “The Tricky Ethics of Socially Responsible Investing” first appeared on WSJ.com.



Follow Us on Twitter

decision invest more ethically complex than many investors realize.

Related stories with The Wall Street Journal: The big snag in ethical investing

Five things you should know before you start your work day on Sept. 14 -World News
Five things you should know before you start your work day on Sept. 14 2 months ago
Here are a few key stories we're following today in the Financial Post
New plastic Jane Austen 10-pound note launched in UK -World News
New plastic Jane Austen 10-pound note launched in UK 2 months ago
LONDON — A new plastic ten-pound note featuring Jane Austen, one of Britain’s most renowned authors, has gone into circulation. The new ‘tenner’ is the first British banknote with a tactile feature involving a series of raised dots
Sebi orders forensic audit of 3 firms as clampdown on shell cos continues -World News
Sebi orders forensic audit of 3 firms as clampdown on shell cos continues 2 months ago
Sebi has observed that Edynamics Solutions Ltd, Info-Drive Software Ltd and Trinity Tradelink Ltd were involved in misrepresentation of books of accounts
Newly famous Wayne Rooney's 'kiss and cuddle' party girl flashes the cash donating money to homeless man as she heads to London -World News
Newly famous Wayne Rooney's 'kiss and cuddle' party girl flashes the cash donating money to homeless man as she heads to London 2 months ago
Wayne and Coleen's marriage was rocked when he was found drunk at the wheel of Laura's car
'We stand together': Rylan Clark-Neal's rarely seen step-son Cameron, 17, poses with parents for gay rights campaign  -World News
'We stand together': Rylan Clark-Neal's rarely seen step-son Cameron, 17, poses with parents for gay rights campaign 2 months ago
The star and his husband are lending their support to the 'Come Out For LGBT' campaign
LeBron James Names His Top Sneakers to Flex in and Play In -World News
LeBron James Names His Top Sneakers to Flex in and Play In 2 months ago
Just last week, we got to sit down with the King of the court, LeBron James for an exclusive one-to-one interview to talk all things basketball, fashion and of course sneakers. With his latest Nike LeBron 15 set to drop next month, it was only fitting to
Japanese billionaire Taizo Son to invest in food and agritech startups in India -World News
Japanese billionaire Taizo Son to invest in food and agritech startups in India 2 months ago
Masayoshi Son’s younger brother Taizo invests in startups from his personal wealth, and does not face constraints of VCs. He’s thinking long-term with new accelerator Gastrotope.
N. Korea threatens to sink Japan into sea with nuclear bomb -World News
N. Korea threatens to sink Japan into sea with nuclear bomb 2 months ago
A North Korean government panel threatened to sink Japan into the sea with a nuclear bomb, accusing it of taking part in U.S. efforts for the adoption of the latest U.N. Security Council sanctions resolution against Pyongyang, the Korean Central News Agen
We all have a choice in our life which is sometimes unmanageable -World News
We all have a choice in our life which is sometimes unmanageable 2 months ago
We all have a choice in our life which is sometimes unmanageable Fortunately, there is not one person on the globe who prom
Sometimes we Need to do Something Wrong to Learn what is Right. -World News
Sometimes we Need to do Something Wrong to Learn what is Right. 2 months ago
Sometimes we Need to do Something Wrong to Learn what is Right   No one ever encounter somebody who can do everything perfectly, but we see people improve their life and learn from the mistakes (wro
AKB48 sets a chart record, but Daoko and Kenshi Yonezu are playing the long game -World News
AKB48 sets a chart record, but Daoko and Kenshi Yonezu are playing the long game 2 months ago
Call it the end of an era. Last week, AKB48’s 49th single “#Sukinanda” sold over 1 million copies to take the top spot on the ...
WADA clears 95 Russian doping cases in probe -World News
WADA clears 95 Russian doping cases in probe 2 months ago
The World Anti-Doping Agency has dismissed all but one of the first 96 Russian doping cases forwarded its way from sports federations acting on information ...