Is Apple’s new iPhone’s facial recognition really more secure? -

Is Apple’s new iPhone’s facial recognition really more secure?

Credit: marketwatch.com

  • Sep 13 2017 16:50About: 2 months ago
  • 2 views

Apple’s iPhone has repeatedly popularized new methods to replace the password, swapping the passcode for fingerprints, and now, facial recognition. But does the iPhone X’s Face ID really offer users more security than Touch ID as Apple claims?

Apple’s AAPL, -1.04%   Face ID technology works using its “TrueDepth” camera system, invisibly projecting 30,000 dots over a user’s face to create a 3D detailed mathematical model to verify their identity. The device can learn a user’s face and detect it even when its appearance and behavior changes. Users’ eyes have to be open and engaging with the device to unlock it, preventing the phone from being hacked by someone using a stolen photo. (Apple did not respond to request for comment.)

Don’t miss: How to get Apple’s new iPhone for half price

The tech giant claims the technology has a false acceptance rate (FAR) of 1 per 1 million whereas Touch ID has a 1 per 50,000 FAR, making it about 20 times more difficult to spoof than Touch ID. The technology can accurately determine if an adversary is trying to use a picture or video of the victim, according to Bojan Simic, chief technology officer of social media analytics company HyPR Brands, due to its “liveness” detection which monitors facial movements to determine a person’s identity. “It looks like Apple has introduced a very effective and easy to use algorithm into the market,” he said.

Still, other experts are not convinced. “This is a high-risk move for Apple, especially in the wake of the Equifax breach,” Matt Schulz, the senior industry analyst at CreditCards.com, said. “That debacle has put data security front and center in people’s minds. If Apple’s facial recognition tool proves to be significantly flawed, it could really damage Apple’s hopes for Apple Pay expansion. People simply won’t use a payments tool if they don’t think it is safe.”

The security of facial recognition has been questioned in the past, largely due to the ability of others to scan someone’s face without their permission. In theory, this would make it easier for law enforcement to open a phone, as a face scan would not violate fifth amendment rights.

It can also be more difficult than other biometrics to capture a face image, according to a study from information security company the SANS Institute, and less user-friendly for people with darker skin tones. “Select Hispanic, black and Asian individuals can be more difficult to enroll and verify in some facial-scan systems because acquisition devices are not always optimized to acquire darker faces,” the SANS institute wrote.

Read also: Why Apple’s new iPhone is bad — for the environment

Apple reports to have overcome weaknesses in facial recognition in development, “but it remains to be seen how Face ID compares to Touch ID in practice for users,” Jason Chaikin, president of fingerprint sensor and biometric authentication company Vkansee — who obviously has a vested interest in fingerprint sensors — says facial recognition security comes down to a variety of factors, including resolution of image capture, brightness, 3D details. “Fingerprint is traditionally much more secure than face, and iris is traditionally even more secure than fingerprint,” he said.

In Apple’s case, it’s more likely users will be frustrated their phone is experiencing a false negative — locking them out of the device — than a false positive, mistaking someone else for them, Frances Zelazny, vice president of global cybersecurity startup BioCatch. One security method alone will always have its pros and cons, he added. Because of that, he suggests two- or three-factor authentication, such as fingerprint scans and traditional number passcodes.



Follow Us on Twitter

Experts there more secure ways unlocking your smartphone.

Related stories with Is Apple’s new iPhone’s facial recognition really more secure?

Eldorado Gold receives two permits from Greek government, other issues remain -World News
Eldorado Gold receives two permits from Greek government, other issues remain 2 months ago
VANCOUVER — Eldorado Gold Corp. (TSX:ELD) says it has received two key permits related to its operations in Greece, but that several issues remain outstanding. The Canadian gold miner says it has received its Olympias operating permit and the modifi
Report questions the need to build new pipelines from the oilsands -World News
Report questions the need to build new pipelines from the oilsands 2 months ago
TORONTO — A new report by the Centre for International Governance Innovation is questioning the need for new pipelines to carry oilsands production to tidewater for export. Jeff Rubin, a senior fellow at the centre and a former chief economist at CI
The Latest: Tech-oriented grad school opens in New York City -World News
The Latest: Tech-oriented grad school opens in New York City 2 months ago
NEW YORK — The Latest on the official opening of a new tech-oriented graduate school in New York City (all times local): 12:30 p.m. Public officials and university leaders have dedicated a new technology-oriented graduate school in New York City. De
'Time-bound listing' plan for PSUs not happening -World News
'Time-bound listing' plan for PSUs not happening 2 months ago
The 'time-bound listing' for public sector undertakings (PSUs), announced in this year's Union Budget, isn't being met.A state-owned unit was to list within 165 days after its Initial Public Offer of equity (IPO) got approval by its parent ministry or dep
Larry King Reveals His Secret Lung Cancer Diagnosis -World News
Larry King Reveals His Secret Lung Cancer Diagnosis 2 months ago
Larry King has conquered 60 years in broadcasting, but now he's fighting a new battle. The TV host exclusively reveals in the new issue of Us Weekly that he was secretly diagnosed with lung cancer.King, 83, received the news during a routin
Danielle Lombard Defends Her Relationship With Dean Unglert in 'Bachelor In Paradise': 'I Wouldn't Change Anything' -World News
Danielle Lombard Defends Her Relationship With Dean Unglert in 'Bachelor In Paradise': 'I Wouldn't Change Anything' 2 months ago
It was real! Bachelor in Paradise may have come to an end, but it left lasting effects on contestant Danielle Lombard. The 27-year-old business owner took to Instagram on Wednesday, September 12, to explain that she had a deep connection with DeanThis art
Clint Eastwood, Jay Leno, More to Help Homeless Cats in Los Angeles  -World News
Clint Eastwood, Jay Leno, More to Help Homeless Cats in Los Angeles 2 months ago
This article originally appeared on www.usmagazine.com: Clint Eastwood, Jay Leno, More to Help Homeless Cats in Los Angeles
Jedi Bible is released for followers of Star Wars 'religion' who want to use the Force for good -World News
Jedi Bible is released for followers of Star Wars 'religion' who want to use the Force for good 2 months ago
The sci-fi self-help book has been written by the Church of Jediism founder
BAPE Debuts
BAPE Debuts "DOT CAMO" on a New Military-Inspired Collection 2 months ago
BAPE has just taken the wraps off a new camouflage motif dubbed "DOT CAMO." The striking pattern is embellished on a limited edition series of military-inspired wares for the Fall/Winter 2017 season. Outerwear, bottoms, and accessories made in collaborati
Rob $tone Returns With Two New Tracks -World News
Rob $tone Returns With Two New Tracks 2 months ago
After taking the game by storm back in 2016 with his double platinum selling single "Chill Bill," San Diego rapper Rob $tone has finally returned to the game with two new tracks, "Two Spoons" and "Holy Grail." These are the first two singles from his fort
HYPEBEAST Giveaway: Vetements Rain Coats, Gosha Rubchinskiy x adidas Track Suit, Raf Simons Ozweego IIIs and More -World News
HYPEBEAST Giveaway: Vetements Rain Coats, Gosha Rubchinskiy x adidas Track Suit, Raf Simons Ozweego IIIs and More 2 months ago
HYPEBEAST has teamed up with luxury purveyor LOIT for a three-part giveaway series to celebrate the official launch of the Los Angeles flagship store. To kick off the giveaway, LOIT is offering up: a yellow Vetements raincoat, a Macbook, and a Bang & Oluf