Generous parents take note: Gifts to your adult children could boost their support payments, if a marriage falters -

Generous parents take note: Gifts to your adult children could boost their support payments, if a marriage falters

Credit: financialpost.com

  • Oct 18 2017 20:00About: 1 month ago
  • 5 views

Parents do what they can to help their children. It is now common for children of parents with means to be gifted a down payment for a house or to receive regular cash gifts to supplement their family income.

But if parents consistently support a child and his or her family and improve the family’s lifestyle, what happens when the adult child separates from her spouse?

The Ontario Court of Appeal has twice considered the effect of a parent’s largesse on the adult child’s own child and spousal support obligations — and came to two different conclusions.

In 2015, Bak v. Dobell considered the case of a 41-year-old husband with serious mental health issues, who was unable to become self-sufficient. The husband had a 13-year-old daughter for whom he paid nominal support. Over a number of years, the husband had received generous gifts from his own father for career training and a home. The value of the gifts exceeded $300,000. The husband also received a monthly allowance from his father of $1,700, which made up the vast majority of his monthly income.

The child’s mother asked the court to impute an income based on the husband’s average lifestyle, so that he would be required to pay more child support. Alternatively, she asked that the husband’s gifts be valued and imputed as part of his income for support purposes.

The Court of Appeal reviewed the Child Support Guidelines, which govern child support arrangements throughout Canada. They have as their objective the establishment of a fair standard of support to allow children to benefit from the means of both spouses after separation. The guidelines also aim to reduce conflict, improve efficiency and ensure consistent treatment of spouses and children in similar circumstances by making the calculation of child support more objective. The guidelines begin with the presumption that all payor parents with the same income will pay the same amount of child support.

In deciding whether the husband’s gifts should form part of his income for child support purposes, the court recognized that under the guidelines, a payor’s presumptive income is on the “total income” line item on his tax return. That line item only reflects income that is subject to tax. “It follows that gifts and lifestyle are not included in a payor’s presumptive income because neither is subject to taxation,” the court observed.

The court went on, however, to review Section 19 of the guidelines, which allows income to be imputed to the payor over and above his presumptive income. The circumstances include if a spouse can earn income but refuses to do so, if he or she fails to provide the proper financial disclosure or if there is income received by the payor that is subject to anomalous tax treatment.

The court did not, however, rule out a circumstance where gifts could form part of income on which support is calculated, saying instead that this was “fact specific.”

The court went on to list a number of facts that could be taken into consideration, including the regularity of the gifts, the duration of their receipt, whether they were received during cohabitation and entrenched a particular lifestyle for the family, and whether the gifts did more than provide a basic standard of living. The court also suggested taking into account whether the gifts were intended to support an adult child through a crisis or disability,whether they continued after separation and appeared likely to continue and how they fit in the context of the payor’s entire income.

Ultimately, in Bak, the Court of Appeal decided that the husband did not have to include his father’s gifts in income, as the husband was unable to support himself without the assistance from his father.

Just a month after Bak v. Dobell was released, the Court was again faced with a similar issue in Korman v. Korman. In deciding whether the husband should be imputed with the $50,000 that had been given to him annually and used by him to enhance the family’s lifestyle, the court applied the Bak factors.

In Korman, the court recognized that there had been a settled pattern of monetary gifts to the husband over many years, which maintained the family’s lifestyle and financed specific family expenditures, including the husband’s various business ventures and the children’s private school and camp. In total, over the 10 years preceding separation, the gifts totaled about $1,000,000. They also continued after separation.

While the court recognized that the husband’s parents had no obligation to continue to make these gifts in the future, the court upheld the trial judge’s decision that the gifts reflected the husband’s actual past revenues and likely, his future financial position, and thus could be considered income for the purposes of deciding support payments. Appropriately, the court also acknowledged that if these gifts ended, the husband could always move to vary the amount of support payable.

Generous parents should take note.

Fiancial Post

Laurie H. Pawlitza is a senior partner in the family law group at Torkin Manes LLP in Toronto.

lpawlitza@torkinmanes.com



Follow Us on Twitter

Court rules that $50000 year husband gets from parents should factor determining support payments

Related stories with Generous parents take note: Gifts to your adult children could boost their support payments, if a marriage falters

UK lawmakers vent anger at May's fragile government over welfare reform -World News
UK lawmakers vent anger at May's fragile government over welfare reform 1 month ago
LONDON (Reuters) - Lawmakers from Britain's ruling Conservative Party vented their anger on Wednesday against Prime Minister Theresa May's pursuit of welfare reforms, reinforcing doubts about her authority over a party divided by Brexit.
Correction to Oct. 16 story on Bombardier’s partnership with Airbus -World News
Correction to Oct. 16 story on Bombardier’s partnership with Airbus 1 month ago
MONTREAL — In an Oct. 16 story, The Canadian Press erroneously reported that as a result of Airbus’s majority stake in Bombardier’s CSeries program, the Quebec government’s position will be cut to 19 per cent from 49.5 per cent whe
Airbus shakes up industry with majority stake in Bombardier CSeries program -World News
Airbus shakes up industry with majority stake in Bombardier CSeries program 1 month ago
MONTREAL — European aircraft giant Airbus Group is shaking up the global airline business by buying a majority stake in Bombardier’s CSeries program and assembling the plane in the U.S. to avoid import duties. The two aircraft manufacturers an
Selena Gomez Sends Love to Demi Lovato: ‘I Wish More People Were Like You’ -World News
Selena Gomez Sends Love to Demi Lovato: ‘I Wish More People Were Like You’ 1 month ago
This article originally appeared on www.usmagazine.com: Selena Gomez Sends Love to Demi Lovato: ‘I Wish More People Were Like You’
Mass Shooting Occurs a Mile Away From ‘House of Cards’ Set -World News
Mass Shooting Occurs a Mile Away From ‘House of Cards’ Set 1 month ago
This article originally appeared on www.usmagazine.com: Mass Shooting Occurs a Mile Away From ‘House of Cards’ Set
Fake dentists ply brisk trade in Morocco -World News
Fake dentists ply brisk trade in Morocco 1 month ago
A smart white coat is no proof of being a qualified medical practitioner in Morocco, where fake dentists and other "health professionals" thrive on poverty, sometimes with wretched consequences.
Kenya protesters attack election training site -World News
Kenya protesters attack election training site 1 month ago
Protesters in western Kenya have thrown chairs and destroyed tents where a training camp was being set up for officials to prepare for this month's presidential election.
Kenya election chief casts doubt on 'free, fair' poll -World News
Kenya election chief casts doubt on 'free, fair' poll 1 month ago
Kenya's polls chief has cast doubt on his organisation's ability to hold a credible vote next week, pointing to internal divisions and interference by both major parties.
Samvat 2073: Sensex up 16.6%; investors richer by Rs 25 lakh cr -World News
Samvat 2073: Sensex up 16.6%; investors richer by Rs 25 lakh cr 1 month ago
The benchmark Sensex has gained 4,642.84 points, or 16.61 per cent, in the Hindu Samvat year 2073
Muharat and the aftermath -World News
Muharat and the aftermath 1 month ago
In the past 10 years Muharat trading has ended on a positive note seven times, data compiled by Bloomberg showed
Dominique Rodgers-Cromartie: I messed up -World News
Dominique Rodgers-Cromartie: I messed up 1 month ago
Giants cornerback Dominique Rodgers-Cromartie took part in practice on Wednesday, a day after the team announced that his suspension came to an end after a week. Rodgers-Cromartie spoke to the media after practice and was contrite about his actions leadin
Kelvin Benjamin leaves Panthers practice with knee issue -World News
Kelvin Benjamin leaves Panthers practice with knee issue 1 month ago
Panthers wide receiver Kelvin Benjamin has been on the injury report for a few weeks with a knee problem. But it may be worth seeing what he does the rest of the week, after an unusual addition to the injury report. Via Bill Voth of the team’s offic