‘Every city would die to have this’: What will it take for Canada to win Amazon’s HQ? -

‘Every city would die to have this’: What will it take for Canada to win Amazon’s HQ?

Credit: financialpost.com

  • Sep 13 2017 22:48About: 2 months ago
  • 3 views

If history is any indication, Canadian governments — and their possibly less-enthused taxpayers — may have to empty their pockets if they want to win the sweepstakes for Amazon.com Inc.’s new North American home.

Amazon announced last week it will open a second corporate headquarters on the continent, with the e-commerce giant expecting to spend more than US$5 billion on the project and provide up to 50,000 “high-paying jobs” for the lucky city.

The announcement set politicians’ hearts aflutter across Canada and the United States, leaving them with less than two months to put together a bid before the Oct. 19 deadline for responses.

“Every city would die to have this,” said Walid Hejazi, associate professor of economic analysis and policy at the University of Toronto’s Rotman School of Management.

So far, officials from Montreal, Toronto, Ottawa, Calgary, Edmonton, Vancouver, Halifax and Kitchener-Waterloo have all expressed interest in the project.

But convincing Amazon to locate the campus it is calling HQ2 north of the border could be a tall — not to mention expensive — order for Canadian cities.

Amazon laid out some of its demands in a request for proposal document, hinting that it will take some serious generosity to earn its investment. In addition to voicing a preference for a metropolitan area with a population of more than one million people, Amazon also highlighted the “incentives” a government may wish to offer, mentioning free land costs, grants and tax credits.

“We acknowledge a project of this magnitude may require special incentive legislation in order for the state/province to achieve a competitive incentive proposal,” said the company’s RFP.

“Amazon is in a very, very strong bargaining position,” Hejazi said, adding that the company probably still wants to avoid overplaying its hand for fear of souring relations with their new hosts.

In the past, the federal government has teamed up with provincial governments to offer grants and incentives to encourage large investments from particular businesses.

For example, Ontario and the federal government each gave Ford Motor Co. conditional grants of up to $102.4 million as part of a $1-billion deal announced in March. The grants were to help fund research and development at the company’s Canadian facilities.

Grants add up

In the case of Amazon, grants around that 10 per cent level could cost governments more than $1-billion in total.

In a statement attributed to Economic Development Minister Navdeep Bains, the federal government told the Financial Post, among other things, that “we welcome the opportunity to engage with our provincial and municipal counterparts to attract further investments and resilient jobs.”

Ontario has also provided funding on its own on occasion, including an up to $220-million grant to Cisco Systems Inc. that was announced in 2013, part of a potential $4 billion investment by the tech company. That’s not far off the size to what Amazon is now promising.

“When you have a Cisco locate in Canada and create those kinds of jobs, the whole ecosystem around it is really high-value and beneficial to the Canadian economy,” Hejazi said.

Amazon could end up fielding some exorbitant offers, based on recent developments.

Wisconsin is currently weighing a US$3-billion incentive package for Taiwan’s Foxconn Technology Group, in return for a new US$10-billion liquid-crystal display plant.

The U.S. also has a penchant for throwing big money at stadiums, such as the New York Yankees receiving $431 million in federal subsidies, according the Brookings Institution, despite being one of the most valuable franchises in sports.

Taxing issues

Governments seeking Amazon’s site may be better off just slashing taxes, suggested Jeffrey Miron, director of economic studies at the libertarian Cato Institute and a senior lecturer at Harvard University.

“I suspect they’re going to have to more or less promise not to impose any significant business taxes, like corporate income taxes,” Miron said in a phone interview. “Because that’s basically what the kind of deals that other big manufacturers have gotten from certain cities, is to really get out from under the vast majority of standard business income taxes.”

U.S. President Donald Trump may also be loath to let one of the biggest companies in the world to take 50,000 jobs to Canada.

But given how contentious his immigration policies have been in Silicon Valley, the Trump factor may actually play to Canada’s advantage.

“In the current political environment, we’re very, very attractive because we’re inside North America, we have a prime minister and a government that’s really open to allowing people to come in,” Hejazi said.

Miron said the decision for a government should come down to a “thoughtful evaluation” of the situation. However, he added, if the job or wage estimates end up being overly rosy, or a government ends up shelling more than they intended, it may not be as sensible.

“And then it’s just a handout to Amazon.”

gzochodne@postmedia.com
Twitter: @geoffzochodne



Follow Us on Twitter

Related stories with ‘Every city would die to have this’: What will it take for Canada to win Amazon’s HQ?

Airlines work to restore normal operations after hurricanes -World News
Airlines work to restore normal operations after hurricanes 2 months ago
WASHINGTON — Airline executives say their carriers are gradually restoring normal operations in the wake of the back-to-back hurricanes that hit Texas and Florida. American Airlines CEO Doug Parker told an industry conference in Washington on Wednes
Mandy Moore Is Reportedly Engaged to Boyfriend Taylor Goldsmith -World News
Mandy Moore Is Reportedly Engaged to Boyfriend Taylor Goldsmith 2 months ago
Cue the wedding bells! Mandy Moore is reportedly engaged to boyfriend Taylor Goldsmith.The “Candy” singer, 33, was spotted at Caffe Luxxe in L.A.’s Brentwood neighborhood on Tuesday, September 12, flaunting what appears to be an engag
Yolanda Hadid Is Finally Living Her Truth With the Release of Her New Book: 'It's a Good Place' -World News
Yolanda Hadid Is Finally Living Her Truth With the Release of Her New Book: 'It's a Good Place' 2 months ago
Yolanda Hadid has a lot to celebrate. The reality star made an appearance at Us Weekly’s 2017 Most Stylish New Yorkers bash, which was sponsored by Stella Artois,This article originally appeared on www.usmagazine.com: Yolanda Hadid Is Finally Livin
Aaron Carter fears he could be HIV-positive as he opens up about health battles and addiction -World News
Aaron Carter fears he could be HIV-positive as he opens up about health battles and addiction 2 months ago
The US pop singer has opened up about his struggles in an emotional tell-all TV interview
Rolls-Royce Looks to the Future of Naval Operations With an Autonomous Ship -World News
Rolls-Royce Looks to the Future of Naval Operations With an Autonomous Ship 2 months ago
Rolls-Royce is exploring fields beyond luxury street rides and trying its hand at vehicles that roam the sea instead of the land. Following up the unveiling of the new Phantom VIII, the British manufacturer has revealed a 197-foot-long autonomous vessel
Eastlogue's Fall/Winter 2017 Collection Bridges East and West Sensibilities -World News
Eastlogue's Fall/Winter 2017 Collection Bridges East and West Sensibilities 2 months ago
Although it's been three-plus years since we last featured a seasonal offering from Eastlogue, the Korean brand has been anything but quiet during that time, putting out collection after collection while expanding its international footprint. Here, we pr
Helmut Lang's
Helmut Lang's "Autumn Tour" Capsule by Shayne Oliver Is Now Available 2 months ago
Not long ago, Shayne Oliver of Helmut Lang unveiled the first imagery of the imprint’s merch capsule collection inspired by ravers and youth subculture. Now, fans can purchase the first drop of the limited range that spans hoodies and T-shirts. Collecti
Official Images & Release Date Surface for Nike's Flyknit Trainer
Official Images & Release Date Surface for Nike's Flyknit Trainer "Cirrus Trainer" 2 months ago
Since its return this summer, Nike's Flyknit Trainer has already seen a handful of popular colorway drop, from "Cookies and Cream," to "Pale Grey" and "Sunset Tint." This time around, the Swoosh officially introduces the forthcoming "Cirrus Blue" editi
Garbstore & Surf Is Dead Collide for Politically-Charged 10-Year Anniversary T-Shirt -World News
Garbstore & Surf Is Dead Collide for Politically-Charged 10-Year Anniversary T-Shirt 2 months ago
Earlier this week, we profiled UK institution Garbstore and its talented founder Ian Paley. Both a shop and a museum, Garbstore now has a new spot -- known as Garbstore.Ten -- in London's bustling Covent Garden. Commemorating that major move, the UK outfi
Experience KITH Sport's NYFW Presentation In New Video -World News
Experience KITH Sport's NYFW Presentation In New Video 2 months ago
Athleisure takes the main stage as KITH's second NYFW showcase presented a wide range of looks all holding inspiration from athletics. Dubbed Kith Sport, Ronnie Fieg's latest fashion week presentation consisted of pieces for both men and women with upcomi
How Much Lil Uzi Vert Earned From
How Much Lil Uzi Vert Earned From "XO Tour Llif3" 2 months ago
Lil Uzi Vert's "XO Tour Llif3" single has hit number seven on Billboard Hot 100 and has earned a double-platinum certification, all the while raking in $900,000 USD in stream revenue. According to Vulture, Uzi's cut comes from a $4.5 million USD earning