The Real Reason United Won’t Be Fined for Dragging David Dao Off That Plane -

The Real Reason United Won’t Be Fined for Dragging David Dao Off That Plane

Credit: fortune.com

  • About: 7 days ago
  • 2 views

Last week, the U.S. Department of Transportation decided not to pursue civil rights charges against United Airlines for its mistreatment of passenger David Dao, the 69-year-old physician dragged off a United flight in April. United broke Dao's nose, gave him a concussion, and knocked out two of his teeth. It also made him an Internet celebrity--the video of Chicago "aviation security officers" dragging him from his seat has been viewed over five million times.

The DOT decision may seem outrageous--one flyers' advocate called it a "dereliction of duty"--but it is a sensible act of prosecutorial discretion that should be applauded, notwithstanding the harm Dao suffered.

If every broken nose resulted in a federal case, the resources of our courts and administrative agencies would be exhausted pursuing matters better deterred through other means. The feds should act only where others cannot or will not, or where markets don't work. The Dao incident was a case in which the wrongdoer got what was coming to them without involving the expensive and fear-inducing machinery of Washington.

Right after he was dragged down the aisle of that United jet, Dao sued United for the damages he suffered. In short order, the parties reached a settlement that presumably resulted in a large cash payment to Dao. Although the terms weren't disclosed, it likely compensated him for his out-of-pocket costs--medical bills, new travel arrangements--as well as the humiliation he felt. If his lawyers were smart, he also got a hefty sum on top of all that.

This extra amount was not about making Dao whole, but about punishing United. After all, the settlement is merely an estimate of the amount Dao would win at trial, less the costs of bringing the case that far. And, it was pretty clear that at trial, his lawyers would have asked for, and a reasonable jury would have awarded, a sum that was intended to protect other people from United (and other airlines). To do this, the award had to send a message: Beating up passengers is going to cost you. That Dao (and his lawyers) got this money was just a strange feature of a legal system that relies to a large extent on private litigation to deter wrongdoing.

The video, controversy, and ensuing case caused United to change its policies. Immediately, it significantly upped the amount it was willing to compensate displaced passengers. Now, passengers can receive up to $10,000 if they find themselves like Dao--involuntarily bumped. The airline also promised to reduce overbooking and to never again remove a boarded passenger. The negative publicity of the event and the public pressure that resulted caused United to dramatically improve its conduct.

brightcove.createExperiences();

 

It was against this backdrop that the Department of Transportation made its determination. As a government agency, the DOT enforces statutes passed by Congress and rules it promulgates. But its core function is to incentivize good behavior on the part of airlines and others under its jurisdiction. If it believed that the private lawsuit and the negative publicity were insufficient to protect the traveling public, then it could levy fines or punish United in other ways. In this case, the allegation was that Dao's "civil rights" were violated. But, short of a finding that he was targeted on the basis of a protected category--such as his race or gender or religious belief--this was a stretch. In addition, federal agencies usually only act when there is a "pattern or practice" of bad behavior. There was no evidence of other Daos in the record, and this saved United from additional sanctions.

This narrow conception of federal power makes sense. Lawyers, like those representing Dao, act as private attorneys general. Where they can do the work of deterrence without spending taxpayer money, then we all benefit. Likewise for the public pressure brought by Internet-fueled outrage. United was pressured--in court and in the court of public opinion--to be better, and it didn't cost John and Jane Q. Public anything. This is a win for all of us, not a setback to the cause of civil rights or the wellbeing of airline passengers.

Todd Henderson is the Michael J. Marks Professor of Law & Mark Claster Mamolen Research Scholar at The University of Chicago Law School.

Follow Us on Twitter

Related stories with The Real Reason United Won’t Be Fined for Dragging David Dao Off That Plane

Celebrity MasterChef: Lesley Garrett reduced to TEARS...but you won't believe why -World News
Celebrity MasterChef: Lesley Garrett reduced to TEARS...but you won't believe why 7 days ago
CELEBRITY MASTERCHEF cooked up a storm this evening, but contestant Lesley Garrett was seen to break down over her uncooked eggs.
Doctor Foster season 2: Gemma’s new man James is hiding a BIG secret - be VERY afraid!  -World News
Doctor Foster season 2: Gemma’s new man James is hiding a BIG secret - be VERY afraid! 7 days ago
DOCTOR FOSTER sent viewers wild last night as their heroine enjoyed a steamy romp with her new man James.
Selena Gomez: Justin Bieber Fans Are Bullying My Assistant! -World News
Selena Gomez: Justin Bieber Fans Are Bullying My Assistant! 7 days ago
It's been over a year since the last time Selena Gomez and Justin Bieber broke up.
Most actively traded companies on the TSX -World News
Most actively traded companies on the TSX 7 days ago
Some of the most active companies traded Wednesday on the Toronto Stock Exchange: Toronto Stock Exchange (15,126.81, down 16.60 points): Eldorado Gold Corp. (TSX:ELD). Miner. Up 38 cents, or 15.77 per cent, to $2.79 on 9.1 million shares. The Canadian gol
US West’s wildfires spark calls to thin tree-choked forests -World News
US West’s wildfires spark calls to thin tree-choked forests 7 days ago
SALEM, Ore. — Wildfires that are blackening the American West in one of the nation’s worst fire seasons have ignited calls, including from Interior Secretary Ryan Zinke, to thin forests that have become so choked with trees that they are at &#
Is this market heading for a cliff? Mixed signals suggest its time to be wary -World News
Is this market heading for a cliff? Mixed signals suggest its time to be wary 7 days ago
There are plenty of mixed signals these days. Canadian markets are in the doldrums, but the economy is going gangbusters
Northern Ireland enters fight to defend Bombardier in dispute with Boeing -World News
Northern Ireland enters fight to defend Bombardier in dispute with Boeing 7 days ago
MONTREAL — The United Kingdom is allying itself with Canada in the fight to persuade U.S. aircraft manufacturer Boeing to abandon its complaint against Bombardier regarding the CSeries. Days after a phone call on the issue between British Prime Mini
Scarlett Johansson and Romain Dauriac Finalize Their Divorce  -World News
Scarlett Johansson and Romain Dauriac Finalize Their Divorce 7 days ago
It’s officially over. Scarlett Johansson and Romain Dauriac have finalized their divorce after two years of marriage, Us Weekly can confirm.The amicable exes confirmed the news in a joint statement to Us: “We remain close friends and coparen
Amber Tamblyn Writes Open Letter to James Woods: 'You Can Change' -World News
Amber Tamblyn Writes Open Letter to James Woods: 'You Can Change' 7 days ago
She won’t be silenced. After actor James Woods denied ever trying to pick up Amber Tamblyn when she was only 16 years old, The Sisterhood of the Traveling Pants actress is fighting back.Tambyln,This article originally appeared on www.usmagazine.com
Spandau Ballet slam ex-singer Tony Hadley's
Spandau Ballet slam ex-singer Tony Hadley's "bullsh**" reason for quitting band 7 days ago
The singer said in July he made the decision to leave the rock group “with regret”
Lily Allen will be honoured at Diversity in Media Awards for her efforts to help Grenfell Tower victims -World News
Lily Allen will be honoured at Diversity in Media Awards for her efforts to help Grenfell Tower victims 7 days ago
EXCLUSIVE: The singer is going to be presented with a special award